Gone with the Wind

Praised it as an ambitious production and an "interesting story beautifully told," despite not considering it the greatest film ever made.

Considered it a major industry event but a minor artistic achievement, criticizing its lengthy "spectacular efficiency," unconvincing drama, and weak second half.

Suggested the film would benefit from trimming "repetitious scenes and dialog," but praised Clark Gable's performance and highlighted Olivia de Havilland as a "standout."

Believed the film had not aged well, losing its epic theme in unconvincing sentimentality as personal lives took over the second half.

Argued the film lacked memorable imagery and dialogue, suggesting it was "badly written" with "flowery" dialogue, making it largely forgettable.

Found the film largely forgettable, stating he could only recall two scenes vividly from the entire experience.

Characterized it as a "rear attack" on history and "Negro people," a "nostalgic plea" for Southern reaction, criticizing its stereotypical black portrayals.

Called the film a "subtle lie" that would be mistakenly accepted as truth by millions due to its insidious misrepresentation of history.

Criticized Hattie McDaniel's character, Mammy, and the film's racial implications, accusing McDaniel of being an "Uncle Tom."